EoFF Mafia XXVIII Game Thread - Banquet of the Voyager Witches

[Scruffington]

Except she has actual, valid reasons to suspect Nutty other than mognets

I did not see the mognet messages and came to assume the same as her

I explained why this could be the case earlier. You see someone messaging someone else, assume they are mafia, but you can't use that as evidence because it's practically cheating and poor form. So instead you have to either use an ability or scumhunt them down.

Well like I already EXPLAINED my issues with his purple statement, which he is ignoring, because now everything I say is just "but because of messages"

I feel like friggin Hillary Clinton up in here

Well what he's positing (which I can somewhat understand) is that you seeing him messaging someone is the basis for your suspicion. Obviously you're bringing up some valid reasons for painting him as mafia now, but I think he's suggesting that you wouldn't have been suspicious (or as suspicious of him) in the first place had you not seen him messaging someone.

@Fynn: Nutty already admitted that he and TSoL are mafia.

[Fynn]

Where did he do that?

[Scruffington]

Where did he do that?

It was brought to me. It is why I didn't bring it up too, but it is funny that it is Bobby and I that are witches, and she brought up to Karifean that we were mognetting each other.

[Fynn]

While I believe that they are mafia, I doubt he intentionally outed himself and Bobby and probably meant something else

[Pumpkin]

For the record I never mention who I saw messaging each other in the mognet I sent to Karifean so that kind of further incriminates yourself

Anyways, sorry if I ruined the game guys! I really did believe him when he said they were talking in Discord and I had my suspicions day one but that all sounds like fluff now, so I mean

Sorry guys

[Scruffington]

I have work, so I'll be out until later tonight.

[Fynn]

Cmon guys, no one's ruining the game


Let's just move on, eh? We'll see how much truth there is to everyone's words. For now, we have three votes on Nutty - who knows, he might just flip human when he gets lynched! Wouldn't that be a curveball for the ages!

[Formalhaut]

You've nothing to apologise for. People need to remember that people do other things outside the game. People talk to each outside the game because this is a forum and people talk on forums.

I see nothing wrong with Nutty messaging TSoL. They could be talking about gardening for all I care.

Seriously though, this is something out of nothing. I live with another player so if a message is suspicious then I don't know anymore. Can we drop this, if at all possible? I don't know, this seems to be something that'll only go nowhere and mess things up for people.

[Pumpkin]

Aye, let's move on. While I know who I think the witches are, that doesn't mean I'm correct, and we still have no idea who the cynic is. Or at least I don't

[Fynn]

Yeah, the Cynic is gonna be the worst part of all this

[Formalhaut]

For what it is worth, I still think Nutty was suspicious even before all this happened. My vote sticks.

[Pumpkin]

Imagine if the cynic is also the pained and then we out the cynic and then they go on a mass killing spree?

That would be bad news bears

[Fynn]

Same

[Fynn]

I highly doubt that, to be honest

[Pumpkin]

Yeah me too but you have to admit that would make for a pretty interesting twist